CNN filed a lawsuit against the president and members of his administration when Jim Acosta, a reporter from CNN, was stripped of his press badge shortly after last week's post-midterms press conference. On Friday, Judge Timothy J. Kelly ordered the Trump administration to restore Acosta's press credentials for violation of his right to a fair and transparent process. However, Judge Kelly did not rule that the First Amendment was violated nor did he rule whether Acosta's rude behavior was right or wrong. The ruling simply stated the president can not revoke Acosta's credentials without due process ("a statement of what he did wrong, an opportunity to respond, a final decision"). As a result of Acosta's victory in court, President Trump has announced that the White House will tighten its rules and processes for reporter conduct in order to ensure orderly press conferences and decorum in the White House. CNN vs. President Trump explicitly demonstrates the dynamic between the press and the president.
1. "During the hearing, Judge Kelly appeared to agree with the argument put forth by the administration’s lawyers that the First Amendment did not guarantee a right to enter the White House campus." In addition, press conferences are by invitation. Is getting a press pass a privilege or a right? Is the CNN vs. President Trump case truly an issue of the First Amendment (free press)? Why or why not?
2. Acosta's press pass was removed because of his aggressive behavior and for inappropriately touching a White House intern during the press conference. Do you think the choice to remove Acosta's press credentials was justified? If an individual is dangerous/disruptive during a press conference, should the White House be able to remove the person from the premise without due process?
3. How does the media shape the public's views of the presidency? What evidence has or has not shown that the news media is intent on hurting President Trump's administration? To what extent should the president and his administration be able to hold secrets from the public/press?